Menu
Like and Follow us on Facebook      Follow us on Twitter      .

Sweets & Treats in Fairfield County, Ohio



Cold Stone Creamery
1621 E. Main Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-654-8396
Cold Stone Creamery

Ice cream chain offering design-your-own creations hand-mixed on a granite slab, plus shakes & more.

Located within Tim Hortons.

Hours: Monday-Sunday 5am-10pm

ColdStoneCreamery.com



Crazy 4 Popcorn
618 Forest Rose Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-785-5750
Crazy 4 Popcorn

Savor the smell the minute you enter the front door of this locally owned and operated gourmet popcorn store in downtown Lancaster. Their popcorn is fresh and flavorful and made on site with great care and a high standard of quality. The flavors are nearly endless and samples are always available. 

Crazy 4 Popcorn invites you to enjoy their gourmet popcorn just as their family has for many years. 

Hours: Monday-Saturday 10am-7pm

Crazy4popcorn.com



Dairy Queen Brazier
602 W. Fair Avenue, Lancaster OH 43130
740-654-9610
Dairy Queen

Soft serve ice cream including cones, shakes, blizzards as well as burgers, hot dogs and beverages. 

Hours: Monday-Thursday 11am-9pm, Friday-Saturday 11am-9:30pm, Sunday 11am-9pm

DairyQueen.com



Dairy Queen Brazier of Lancaster
1150 E Main Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-653-7257
Dairy Queen

Soft serve ice cream including cones, shakes, blizzards as well as burgers, hot dogs and beverages. 

Hours: Monday-Thursday 11am-9pm, Friday-Saturday 11am-9:30pm, Sunday 11am-9pm

DairyQueen.com



Dairy Queen Brazier of Pickerington
541 Hill Rd N Pickerington, OH 43147
614-837-8676
Dairy Queen

Soft serve ice cream including cones, shakes, blizzards as well as burgers, hot dogs and beverages. 

Hours: Monday-Thursday 11am-10pm, Friday-Saturday 10:30am-10pm, Sunday 11am-10pm

DairyQueen.com



Das KaffeeHaus von Frau Burkhart
45 E Columbus St, Lithopolis, OH 43136
614-563-1984
Das KaffeeHaus

A one of a kind - authentic German KaffeeHaus located in Lithopolis, Ohio. A European themed coffee house with a very prominent German influence serving high quality European coffee & pastries. The focus of our KaffeeHaus is to serve the BEST quality coffee and pastry products at an exceptional value! 

Come by and enjoy our strong Europäisch thema (European theme) - or what we like to call, “Das” - exceptional coffee, and wondrous Deutsches Gebäck (German pastries). You will find that Das KaffeHaus vFB will instill a yearning in you for not only our delicious traditional German treats, but for our atmosphere – or “Das” as well.

Hours: Monday-Friday 6am -9pm, Saturday and Sunday 8am -9pm

DasKaffeeHaus.us



Four Reasons Bakery & Deli
135 W. Main Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
740- 654-2253
Four Reasons Bakery & Deli

Down-to-earth spot in Historic Downtown Lancaster featuring pastries, ice cream, sandwiches, salads & espresso drinks, plus deli meats & cheeses to go.

Hours: Monday - Friday 6:30 am-4 pm, Saturday 8 am-3 pm, Sunday 9-3 pm

FourReasons.com



Graeter's Ice Cream
51500 Cross Creek Blvd, Pickerington, OH 43147
614) 755-986
Graeter's Ice Cream

Still family owned, Graeter's is the last ice cream still crafted in French Pots, just 2 1/2 gallons at a time. Today, Graeter's has over 50 retail locations offering ice cream and dessert catering! Stop in our Pickerington store location and try our delicious french pot ice cream today!

Hours: Monday-Thursday 11am-10pm, Friday-Saturday 11am-11pm, Sunday 11am-10pm

www.Graeters.com



GypsyJoe's Ice Cream & Donut Co.
2237 W Fair Ave Lancaster, OH 43130
740-687-2400
Gypsy Joe's

Hours: Monday-Thursday 6am-9 pm, Friday-Saturday 6am-10pm, Sunday 7:30am-9pm

GypsyJoesIceCream.com



Happy Goat
745 E. Main Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-621-4628
Happy Goat

Gluten free bakery and bulk food store. Dedicated to making delicious quality gluten-free baked goods. Happy Goat's mission is to provide high quality, gluten-free items to our community. We specialize in sweet, bakery items that warm your heart and fill your belly regardless of allergies and dietary needs. We work with other local small businesses and use as many local ingredients as possible when available.

Hours: Tuesday-Wednesday 12pm-5pm, Thursday-Friday 10am-6pm, Saturday 9am-2pm, Closed Sunday & Monday

HappyGoat.biz



Mabel & Grace Bakery
123 North Broad Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-654-4370
.

Handcrafted artisan breads, cakes, pastries, espresso, and retail wine located in downtown Lancaster.

Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 7am-6pm, Sunday 7am-3pm, Closed Monday

 



Nancy's Scoops
1804 W Fair Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-785-5661
Nancy's Scoops

Locally owned and operated ice cream shop with a sandwich menu and sides from fries to mac & cheese bites. Soft serve and hand-dipped ice cream in all your favorite flavors. Sundaes, Shakes, Artic Swirls and more. 

Hours: Monday-Saturday 11am-9pm, Closed Sunday



Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt
10503 Blacklick Eastern Road, Pickerington, OH 43147
614) 309-9733
Orange Leaf Yogurt

At orange Leaf you're the master of your dessert. We provide the best tasting frozen yogurt on earth, specifically selected toppings, and a bright, fun environment where everyone feels welcome!

Hours: Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday 12pm-9pm, Tuesday 12pm-9:30pm, Friday-Saturday 12pm-10pm

OrangeLeafYogurt.com



Schaffner's Drive In
601 W. Market Street, Baltimore, OH 43105
740-862-6832
Schaffner's Drive In

Schaffner's Drive In is an ice cream and sandwich shop located in Baltimore, Ohio since 1959!

Hours: Monday-Saturday 10:30am-9pm, Sunday 11:30-9pm



Smoothie King
10501 Blacklick Eastern Rd, Pickerington, OH 43147
614-759-9183
Smoothie King

We offer our guests the best-tasting nutritional smoothies and quality snacks.

Hours: Monday-Friday 6:30am-9pm, Saturday 8am-9pm, Sunday 9am-9pm

SmoothieKing.com



Square Seven Coffee House
150 W Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130
740- 653-1755
Square Seven

Square Seven Coffee House is a full-service coffee house located inside Art and Clay on Main in Downtown Lancaster. Square Seven proudly serves Stauf's (Cup O' Joe) Coffee and features great specialty beverages, teas, and fruit smoothies. Square Seven also serves sandwiches using local meats and cheeses from Bay's Food Market. Local pastry items are available throughout the day.

Check our website or facebook page for Live Music Events. 

Hours: Monday-Thursday 7am-6pm, Friday 7am-10pm, Saturday 9am-8pm, Sunday 12pm-4pm

SquareSevenCoffeeHouse.com



Sweet Persuasions Bakery
1260 Hill Road N, Pickerington, OH 43147
614-604-6714
Sweet Persuasions Bakery

Daily bakery items include gourmet coffees, cupcakes, pies, cakes, donuts, cookies and pastries, as well as traditional breakfast items such as quiches.  Only superior quality ingredients and no preservatives are used in all the scratch-made baked goods.

Hours: Tuesday-Saturday 8am-7pm, Closed Sunday & Monday

 



The Confectionary
115 South Columbus Street, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-503-2799
The Confectionary

The Confectionary specializes in cupcakes and miniature confectionary items. We create a unique twist on classic bakery items that will be sure to please your pallet.

Hours: Wednesday-Friday 10am-5:30pm, Saturday 8am-2pm. Closed Sunday & Monday


 



Weldon Olde Fashion Ice Cream Parlor
2887 Canal Drive NE, Millersport, OH 43046
740-467-2400
Weldon's Ice Cream

Founded in 1960, Weldon Ice Cream Company specializes in Ice Cream and Frozen Desserts. Located in the Buckeye Lake Region in Millersport, Ohio, Weldon's has been a family destination for generations.

Visitors and residents of Millersport have enjoyed the delicious homemade ice cream on the front porch overlooking Buckeye Lake. 

Hours: 11am-8pm

Weldons.com



Whit's Frozen Custard-Lancaster
1748 N Memorial Dr Lancaster, OH 43130
740-653-7995
Whit's Frozen Custard

Welcome to Whit's Frozen Custard Made Fresh Daily® (now that's a mouthful!) As our name states, we make our frozen custard fresh every day so you can enjoy the best experience that frozen custard has to offer. And if you knew how much love and care we put into each batch of Whit's frozen custard (we start at 6 am) you'd understand why we only feature three flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, and Whit's Special Weekly Flavor.

Three flavors is all anyone needs to create an endless variety of flavor combinations when you consider all our fruit toppings, nuts, and candies that can be blended into custard to make our famous Whitser™. And you can't go wrong with our hand-dipped waffle cones and all our other delicious treats.

Whit's frozen custard is made fresh daily, right in our stores.

Hours: Sunday-Thursday Noon-9pm, Friday-Saturday Noon-10pm

WhitsCustard.com



Whits Frozen Custard
7520 Hill Road, Canal Winchester, OH 43110
614-834-3370
Whits Frozen Custard

Welcome to Whit's Frozen Custard Made Fresh Daily® (now that's a mouthful!) As our name states, we make our frozen custard fresh every day so you can enjoy the best experience that frozen custard has to offer. And if you knew how much love and care we put into each batch of Whit's frozen custard (we start at 6 am) you'd understand why we only feature three flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, and Whit's Special Weekly Flavor.

Three flavors is all anyone needs to create an endless variety of flavor combinations when you consider all our fruit toppings, nuts, and candies that can be blended into custard to make our famous Whitser™. And you can't go wrong with our hand-dipped waffle cones and all our other delicious treats.

Whit's frozen custard is made fresh daily, right in our stores. This location has an outdoor patio.

Hours: Monday-Thursday 4pm-9pm, Friday 4pm-9:30pm, Saturday & Sunday 2pm-9:30pm

WhitsCustard.com

 



Yo.m.g! (Yogurt Made Great)
1405 Ety Road, Lancaster, OH 43130
740-420-9490
.

Yo.M.G is proud to bring true, live active culture frozen yogurt to Lancaster in Ohio! Come to see us for a delicious and healthy dessert, afternoon snack, or just because you feel like seeing our smiling faces ;) We feature the freshest, creamiest frozen yogurt you'll ever find which will be sure to have you smile right back at us!

Hours: Monday-Saturday 12pm-9pm, Sunday 1:30pm-9pm